One of the easiest ways to overcomplicate local SEO is by building the wrong location page structure. Some sites try to rank everywhere with a single “areas served” page. Others create dozens of thin city and neighborhood pages that split authority and never perform. The real question isn’t how many pages you can build—it’s how many you actually need. In this post, we break down when individual city pages outperform a single areas-served page, how to handle neighborhoods cleanly, and how to keep your site efficient as you scale.
Table of Contents
Start simple: one page per city or town
Our default move is to create a single page for each real city, town, or area that has its own ZIP code. These pages give clear, focused signals to search engines. They let us target the city name, services, and local phrases without spreading relevance too thin.
For most small businesses and single-service providers, that is enough. A dry cleaner, local plumber, or locksmith often does not need dozens of pages. We avoid adding extra pages unless the market forces us to.
Why not pile on neighborhood pages by default?
More pages is not always better. When we create many small pages, we often hurt what we call site efficiency. That means:
- More pages to maintain and update.
- More places where link equity gets split up inside the site.
- More external links needed to rank many pages instead of focusing on a few strong ones.
- Higher risk of thin or repetitive content that the site-wide helpful content rules may penalize.
So for most campaigns, a tighter, smaller site that focuses on the main services and the main cities performs better than a sprawling site with dozens of near-duplicate pages.
Got SEO Questions? Get answers every week at 4pm ET at Hump Day Hangouts. Ask questions ahead of time, or live – just go to: https://semanticmastery.com/hdho (bookmark this!) 10+ years of insights given every week!
Get your checklist to help get better results with GBPs, faster.
How to handle neighborhoods and communities
Instead of making a separate page for every neighborhood, we usually list neighborhoods on the city page. Use a clear subheading like Neighborhoods we serve in [City] and then place the neighborhood names under that. That gives each neighborhood a direct on-page mention without creating extra pages.
Structurally, we recommend using an H2 for the neighborhoods section and H3s for each neighborhood name. That gives those neighborhoods weight in the page structure and helps search engines see the geographic coverage.
When to create separate neighborhood pages
Only make separate neighborhood pages when the competition demands it. If you test a city page and it cannot rank for specific neighborhoods or the traffic and revenue justify the extra work, then create supporting pages.
When we do add neighborhood pages, we follow a simple pattern:
- Keep a parent city page with the H2 and H3 list of neighborhoods.
- Make each neighborhood H3 clickable to open the supporting page.
- On each neighborhood page, link back to the parent city page.
This keeps the structure logical and helps funnel internal link equity where it matters.
Think about link building and efficiency
Consider how links will work. If we have one city page, that is one target for links. If we add 12 neighborhood pages, we now have 13 targets. Our link budget gets spread thinner. That reduces the power of each link and slows down results.
We prefer to keep link targets few and strong. If a city page can win with good content and a few quality links, we double down there first.
Decision checklist: which approach to choose
Use this simple checklist to decide:
- Market size: Does the city or area have its own ZIP code and local identity? If yes, make a city page.
- Service type: Is the business a single service in a small area (dry cleaner, locksmith)? Start with minimal pages.
- Competition: Are competitors ranking with many neighborhood pages? Test a single city page first, then add pages if needed.
- Resources: Do we have the time and link budget to support many pages? If not, focus on fewer pages that are stronger.
- Performance: Launch the minimal structure, watch results, then add pages only when performance shows they are needed.
Examples that make sense
Example 1: A local plumber that serves three nearby towns. We build one page per town. On each town page, we list the neighborhoods. No neighborhood pages needed.
Example 2: A roofing company in a big metro area with heavy competition. We start with city pages. If a city page cannot beat competitors for certain neighborhoods, we add neighborhood landing pages and link them in from the city page.
What to include on each city page
- Clear H1 with the city name and primary service.
- A short paragraph that explains the service area.
- An H2 titled “Neighborhoods we serve in [City]” with H3s for each neighborhood.
- Local proof: photos, testimonials, case studies tied to that city.
- Contact info and a local call to action.
Keep content focused and useful
We want pages that read well for people and for search. That means short, useful paragraphs, clear headings, and real local details. Avoid copy-paste content that changes only the city name. Thin, repetitive content hurts long-term performance.
Final rule: start small and expand with proof
The safest, smartest path is to start with the minimum pages that make sense for your business. Watch how each page performs. If you need more coverage for a specific area or neighborhood, add pages in a controlled way. This keeps the site efficient, makes link building easier, and often leads to faster wins in local search.
FAQ
Is one “Areas Served” page ever enough?
It can be for very small businesses that serve a single small area. But as a rule, one city page per meaningful target area is better for ranking in multiple cities.
How do we list neighborhoods without making pages?
Use an H2 called “Neighborhoods we serve in [City]” and list neighborhoods as H3s under it. That gives on-page mentions and structure without creating extra pages.
When should we create separate neighborhood pages?
Only after testing a city page and seeing it cannot win for key neighborhoods, or when competition is very high and the return justifies extra work.
Won’t fewer pages mean fewer chances to rank?
Fewer, stronger pages often rank better than many weak pages. We want to concentrate relevance and links on the pages that matter.
How does this affect link building?
With fewer target pages, our link budget goes further. We can make each link more impactful by pointing it to a single strong page instead of many thin pages.
Short checklist to follow now
- Create one page per city or town that matters to your business.
- Add a neighborhoods section on each city page with H3s for each neighborhood.
- Test performance for a few weeks or months.
- If a neighborhood needs extra focus, create a supporting page and link it to the city page.
- Keep content local, helpful, and not repeated across pages.
Keep the site focused. Make fewer pages that do more. That is the path to better local SEO results without wasting time or budget.