Starting an SEO agency from scratch is less about branding and location and more about focus. Most agencies struggle early because they try to serve everyone, chase every lead, and reinvent their process for every client. That slows results and burns time fast. In this post, we lay out how we would start over today—by choosing a single industry, validating demand, building one repeatable playbook, and scaling through duplication instead of guesswork.
Table of Contents
Why industry focus beats location
Geography feels important. It seems smart to say our agency is downtown or in a big city. But that idea can become a distraction fast. When we pick one industry and learn it well, everything gets easier.
Here is why focusing on one industry works better:
- Repeatable work: Once we find what converts, we can copy it for other clients in the same field.
- Faster results: We stop guessing and start using proven tactics that actually bring calls, leads, or sales.
- Shorter sales cycles: Clients trust us faster when we speak their language and show results for similar businesses.
- Less wasted time: We stop writing long proposals for industries we do not know.
How to choose the right industry
Pick an industry that meets three simple rules:
- There are many businesses in that industry.
- The businesses spend money on marketing.
- We can understand their problems and offers.
We do not need to love the industry at first. We do need to like working with the people and care about their results. If they spend on marketing, we can get paid to grow them.
Validate before you commit
Spend a few days to validate an industry before full focus. Validation steps:
- Search for local businesses in that industry. Are there many?
- Call a few owners. Ask about how they get customers now and if they have marketing budgets.
- Look at competitors. Are other agencies already serving them? If so, how are they doing it?
- Run one small test campaign or offer a fixed-price audit to a single business to see if results are possible.
Got SEO Questions? Get answers every week at 4pm ET at Hump Day Hangouts. Ask questions ahead of time, or live – just go to: https://semanticmastery.com/hdho (bookmark this!) 10+ years of insights given every week!
Get your checklist to help get better results with GBPs, faster.
Build one repeatable playbook
Once we pick an industry, we build a playbook that covers the whole client journey. The playbook should include:
- Sales script: A short pitch that explains how we help businesses in that industry.
- Onboarding checklist: What we need from the client and what we deliver first.
- SEO and conversion steps: The exact pages, keywords, and offers that work.
- Creative templates: Ad copy, landing pages, and images that convert.
- Reporting template: A simple set of metrics that show progress and wins.
When one playbook works, we can sell it to many businesses in different cities without reinventing the work each time.
Scale by duplication, not reinvention
The fastest way to scale is to replicate what works. We take the same playbook and apply it to other markets. Each new client becomes a copy of the same process. That gives us:
- Lower delivery costs because we reuse assets.
- Faster onboarding because the steps are standard.
- Better case studies because we have many similar wins.
Why ranking your agency locally can slow you down
Ranking your own agency in your city sounds smart. But doing that often brings a stream of random leads. These leads can be from many different industries. We end up writing long proposals for businesses we know little about. That wastes time and lowers close rates.
Instead, we want leads from the industry we serve. If we rank for industry-specific terms, the right clients find us.
If you must start local, pick suburbs not the big city
If our plan is to target local businesses early, stay close to home and pick less crowded areas. Suburbs or smaller towns are easier to win in. Reasons:
- Less competition: Fewer agencies fight for the same clients.
- Faster wins: Improvements show up sooner in local search.
- Lower stress: We can test and refine our process without pressure.
Do not try to compete in a big metro area until our system is proven and repeatable.
Practical first 30-day plan
- Pick one industry that meets the three rules above.
- Talk to 5 business owners in that industry.
- Run a quick audit or offer a low-cost trial to 1 business.
- Create a one-page playbook that lists the steps that worked in the trial.
- Use that one-page playbook to close 2 more clients in nearby markets.
Repeat steps 4 and 5 until the process becomes faster and you have clear proof of results.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Chasing every lead that comes to the inbox. Decline clients outside the chosen industry.
- Trying to be an expert in five different fields at once. That slows learning.
- Rushing into big-city competition before the playbook works without help.
- Spending hours on proposals for industries we do not know. Keep proposals short and tested.
How to price when you start
Start with value-based pricing. Price based on the value you add rather than hourly work. For the first clients, consider a smaller fixed fee plus a performance bonus. This reduces the buyer risk and shows confidence in our method.
One sentence summary
Pick one industry, learn it, make a repeatable playbook, then copy that playbook into other markets instead of chasing a fancy address.
Should we list our agency downtown using a virtual office?
Listing a downtown address can bring leads, but they will be mixed across many industries. If we want targeted industry clients, avoid faking a downtown setup. If we must, keep local targeting limited to nearby suburbs where competition is lower.
How many industries should we try at first?
Start with one. Learn it until we have a clear, repeatable playbook. After that, we can add a second industry only if it fits our systems and team.
What if an owner wants services outside our chosen industry?
Either refer them to someone else or offer a very limited, fixed-scope test. Keep the main focus on the industry we know so our results and reputation grow.
Can we still do local SEO while focusing on an industry?
Yes. We should target local keywords for that industry in different cities. This gets clients in those areas without forcing us to serve random business types.
Final notes
Starting an agency is hard. We make it easier by narrowing our focus. Specializing in one industry speeds learning, improves conversions, and lowers wasted work. Location matters less than the work we repeat and refine. Keep the first steps small, prove the model, then scale by duplication.