Local lead generation still works, but it no longer works the way it used to. Relying on fragile Google Business Profiles or expecting organic-only sites to carry a business model is a fast way to hit instability. The landscape has shifted toward maps, paid placements, and defensible assets that support real sales conversations. In this post, we break down where leads actually come from now, why some old models struggle, and how to structure lead gen so it still produces revenue in today’s SEO environment.
Table of Contents
Where the leads are coming from now
Search results have been rearranged. For most local searches the page looks like this:
- Local service ads (Google Guaranteed) at the very top.
- Regular paid search ads below that.
- Maps pack with paid placements sometimes mixed in.
- The first non-paid organic result appears far down, often below the fold.
That means most organic-only pages get little visibility for local searches. The maps pack and paid placements are where the leads live. If our goal is volume, we need to optimize for maps and paid placements, not just organic results.
Why Google Business Profiles are a risky foundation
Google Business Profiles can drive a lot of leads, but they come with big risks. Profiles get flagged, put into re-verification, or suspended. Video verification and other safeguards have made it much harder to maintain multiple profiles that we do not fully control.
When a profile is suspended, recovery is often slow or impossible. That makes a business model based on spammy or loosely controlled profiles a house of cards. We don’t want to spend time and resources rebuilding listings over and over. That’s not a sustainable way to run a business.
How to use organic lead gen sites the smart way
Organic sites still have a role. They no longer produce the same direct lead volume, but they are powerful as sales tools. Here’s how we use them:
- Build a clean, organic-only site for a specific service area and keyword set.
- Get that site to rank enough to show up in searches and outrank local competitors.
- Use the site as proof when prospecting local businesses. We can say,
“Look, I'm not even in your area. This new site is already outperforming your own site.”
- Offer the site as an exclusive support asset if the business signs a contract with us.
This approach shifts the site from being the product to being the credibility tool that helps us win clients. Once we win the client, we then build a proper, defensible lead flow with map optimization, reputation work, paid ads, and local funnels.
Got SEO Questions? Get answers every week at 4pm ET at Hump Day Hangouts. Ask questions ahead of time, or live – just go to: https://semanticmastery.com/hdho (bookmark this!) 10+ years of insights given every week!
Get your checklist to help get better results with GBPs, faster.
Why renting sites for big monthly fees is harder than it looks
Rank-and-rent was a popular model where operators rented sites or listings to local businesses for monthly fees. On paper it sounds simple: build, rank, rent, profit. In practice there are problems:
- Higher monthly fees are hard to sustain unless the asset produces strong, steady lead volume.
- Seasonal businesses often pause payments in slow months, creating churn.
- When organic visibility drops, rental income drops and we have to find new buyers.
We experimented with low-cost rentals like $99/month and higher rents like $500–$1,000/month. The low-cost model kept buyers longer but earned less. Higher rents gave better return but more turnover and headaches. Over time the steady work of replacing buyers and handling seasonal churn made this model less attractive.
How to structure a modern local lead gen business
Keep things simple and repeatable. The modern approach looks like this:
- Build defensible assets. Clean websites, good content, proper hosting, and local signals. Avoid tricks that can get flagged.
- Optimize for maps first. Map visibility is where most of the lead volume is. GBP work can help, but don't rely on spammy profiles.
- Use organic sites as proof. Let these sites show your ability to rank and to drive traffic. Use them to open doors with local businesses.
- Offer the site as a bonus or exclusive asset. Rather than renting out the site as the main product, make it a selling point in a broader marketing service package.
- Set realistic pricing. Instead of charging high monthly rents, price services so they match predictable value to the client. Consider performance-based elements, but keep a base retainer.
- Focus on relationships and retention. A leased asset without client retention is an unstable income stream. Build services that clients keep year-round.
We should treat the organic site as a way to prove our work and start conversations. The real lead volume will come from maps, ads, and reputation management once the client is onboarded.
What about AI search and Gemini?
AI-driven search is changing how people find answers. Systems like Gemini are starting to surface direct answers instead of directing users to a list of links. That creates a new open field for lead generation models tuned to AI results.
We do not have a full blueprint yet. However, a few possibilities stand out:
- Create content and structured data tailored to AI summarization so the business becomes the answer source.
- Build flows that convert the AI user into a contactable lead, such as guided forms or click-to-call inside the AI environment.
- Experiment with ownership of AI-accessible assets that are less fragile than profile listings.
In short, AI search is a major opportunity. It will require new content formats, schema, and thought about how answers turn into leads. We should watch it closely and run small tests now.
Quick checklist for moving forward
- Stop building on fragile assets: Avoid relying on spammy GBP tactics.
- Build organic proof sites: Use them to open conversations with local businesses.
- Prioritize map visibility: That is where the leads will come from.
- Offer site as support, not the product: Make it a closing tool or a contract incentive.
- Experiment with AI: Explore new ways to capture leads from AI-driven answers.
FAQ
Is lead generation still worth doing?
Yes. It still works, but we must change tactics. We should focus on creating defensible assets and on maps and paid channels for actual lead volume. Organic sites are best used as proof tools rather than the main source of leads.
Should we keep building Google Business Profiles?
Not as the core business model. Building a few well-managed profiles can help, but avoid spam tactics and multiple risky profiles. Profiles are easy to lose and hard to recover, so do not build a company around them.
Can we still rent out sites for steady income?
You can, but higher monthly rents are harder to sustain. Rental income is unstable when lead volume drops or when clients pause seasonally. Consider using sites as sales incentives instead of primary rental products.
How do we use organic sites to win clients?
Get an organic site to outrank local competitors for targeted keywords. Use that demo during outreach to show capability. Offer exclusive assignment or support of that site if the business signs up with you.
Should we plan for AI-driven search?
Yes. Start small experiments with content that AI systems can use. Think about how answers turn into contactable leads. AI will reshape discoverability, so early testing gives a head start.
Final thought
Lead gen is not dead, but it looks different. We should stop building on shaky listings and instead build assets that prove what we can do. Use those assets to win clients, then create a stable lead flow through maps, ads, reputation, and local funnels. Keep an eye on AI search. It will open new paths for lead generation if we adapt early and smartly.