Deciding where a link asset belongs is less about guesswork and more about risk management. Every domain we control either strengthens the money site directly or supports other assets in the background. The key is knowing which is which. By evaluating how clean a backlink profile is and how closely it matches the target topic, we can consistently decide whether a domain should sit in Tier 1 or Tier 2 and get the most value from every link we build.
Table of Contents
What we mean by Tier 1 and Tier 2
Tier 1 assets link directly to the money site. These should be the cleanest and most relevant domains you own. They pass the most authority and have the biggest impact.
Tier 2 assets link to Tier 1 sites or act as supporting content. These can be a bit less clean or only somewhat relevant. They help boost Tier 1 sites without exposing the money site to risk.
Two simple criteria to decide
We keep the decision simple: look at domain cleanliness and topical relevance.
- Cleanliness — Check the backlink profile for spam, obvious link networks, or toxic links. If the profile is very clean, the domain is a strong candidate for Tier 1.
- Topical relevance — Does this domain naturally match the topic of your money site? The closer the match, the more value it passes.
How to inspect cleanliness and relevance
Here are easy checks we run for each domain.
- Check the anchor text mix. If anchors are mostly exact-match spam, treat the domain with caution.
- Look at referring domains. Lots of low-quality sites linking to it is a red flag.
- Review content and topical signals. Does the site publish content that fits your niche? Is the theme clear?
- Run the usual toxicity checks in your SEO tools. High spam scores push the domain to Tier 2.
Got SEO Questions? Get answers every week at 4pm ET at Hump Day Hangouts. Ask questions ahead of time, or live – just go to: https://semanticmastery.com/hdho (bookmark this!) 10+ years of insights given every week!
Get your checklist to help get better results with GBPs, faster.
Spend smart: buy the best links for Tier 1
When we spend money on links, we place those paid links where they will help the most. That usually means buying links on Tier 1 assets that are both clean and topical. Paid links are an investment, so they should live on our strongest properties.
For cheaper links or internal in-house link work, we use those on Tier 2 assets or on a mix of sites at scale. This keeps our most valuable properties safer and preserves maximum value for the money site.
Why a 100 percent relevant link profile looks strange
It might sound odd, but if every single link pointing to your site is perfectly on-topic, that can look manufactured. Real websites get links from a variety of places. A mixture of relevance levels makes the profile look natural.
That means we do not try to make every link perfectly relevant. Instead we aim for a smart mix:
- Most high-value links are topically relevant and clean.
- Some lower-cost or internal links can be less relevant. They help build scale and variety.
- The overall profile should feel organic, not built by hand only.
When a Tier 2 can act like Tier 1
Sometimes a Tier 2 domain is good enough to be used as a Tier 1. If a domain is not perfect but still pretty clean and somewhat related, we might choose to deploy it as Tier 1 when needed. The rule of thumb is this: the cleanest and most relevant assets stay in Tier 1, but some flexible cases make sense to promote.
Practical link-building checklist
Use this checklist when you decide where a domain belongs.
- Run a backlink audit for spam signals and bad anchor patterns.
- Score topical match between the domain and your money site.
- If both cleanliness and relevance are high, mark as Tier 1.
- If one or both are weak, mark as Tier 2 and keep it supporting other assets.
- Adjust spending: invest in bought links on Tier 1 assets first.
- Keep a mix of relevance levels in your overall profile for natural signals.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Putting a borderline or dirty domain straight into Tier 1. This risks the money site.
- Making every link perfectly on-topic. That creates a pattern that looks forced.
- Spending heavily on links without checking domain fit. Spend where relevance and cleanliness are strongest.
- Forgetting to monitor link velocity. Build at a sensible pace so things look organic.
Examples of decision-making
Example 1: We find a domain that used to be a small blog in our niche. It has clean backlinks from related sites and no spammy anchors. That becomes a Tier 1 site. We put paid links there first.
Example 2: We find a domain with decent traffic but a messy backlink profile and mixed topics. It still has some value. We rebuild it, add useful content, and use it as Tier 2 to push our Tier 1 properties.
Final rules to follow
- Keep the cleanest and most relevant sites at Tier 1.
- Use Tier 2 to protect the money site and to add scale.
- Maintain varied relevance for a natural link profile.
- Spend money where the domain fit is the best.
FAQ
How clean does a domain need to be to become Tier 1?
It should have a low spam score, natural anchor text mix, and links from relevant sites. If the backlink profile raises red flags, keep the domain in Tier 2 until you clean it up.
Can less relevant links ever point directly to my money site?
Yes. A mix of relevance levels looks natural. But prioritize your best, most relevant links for the money site and use less relevant links to add variety.
Should we always use paid links on Tier 1?
Not always, but when we pay for links we want the biggest return. That means placing paid links on clean, relevant Tier 1 properties is usually the best move.
What if a domain is borderline clean and relevant?
Use your judgment. If it is close, you can promote it to Tier 1 for specific campaigns. If you are unsure, keep it as Tier 2 and monitor results while you improve the site.
How do we keep the link profile natural over time?
Vary anchor text, get links from a mix of related and semi-related sites, pace the link building, and use both Tier 1 and Tier 2 assets in your plan. Regular audits help catch patterns that look forced.