Directory outreach often triggers unnecessary anxiety, especially when multiple people appear to be working the same niche. It feels like competition before a sale even happens. In reality, niche overlap is rarely the thing that limits results. What matters far more is how clearly we position the offer, how we speak to prospects, and whether we execute long enough to learn what actually converts. This post breaks down when overlap matters, when it doesn’t, and how to win regardless of who else is in the market.
Table of Contents
Why overlap is usually not a problem
Some people panic when they think another agency or student is doing the same niche. They imagine fighting over the same tiny pool of clients. That rarely matches reality. Most niches are big. For example, there are over 165,000 tree service contractors in the United States. If we captured even a sliver of that market, we'd be fine.
Even if a few people in our group use the same directory template and outreach copy, that does not mean every prospect will choose them. Marketing is about who we attract, not who we ignore. Two agencies can both market to tree services and still win very different clients. Our tone, our offer, and the way we talk to prospects decide who comes on board.
When overlap might actually hurt
Overlap becomes a problem only when the niche is tiny. If there are only a few dozen potential clients in a region, then multiple agencies trying the same play will step on each other's toes. In that case we should consider one of two moves:
- Pick a bigger market nearby or expand geographically.
- Differentiate by narrowing the offer inside the niche. For example, focus on storm cleanup within tree services rather than general tree care.
Most times, though, the market is wide enough that overlap does not matter.
Specialization beats being a me-too agency
Trying to be everything to everyone is a heavy lift. We end up offering a lot of services, but we are not great at any of them. That costs time and lowers profit. Instead, pick one industry and learn it well. Make services that solve common problems in that business. Then repeat the playbook.
When we focus, several good things happen:
- We work less because we sell the same solutions again and again.
- We get better at the pitch, onboarding, and delivery.
- We can charge more because our offer becomes obvious and reliable.
- Clients stay longer because our skills match their needs
Got SEO Questions? Get answers every week at 4pm ET at Hump Day Hangouts. Ask questions ahead of time, or live – just go to: https://semanticmastery.com/hdho (bookmark this!) 10+ years of insights given every week!
Get your checklist to help get better results with GBPs, faster.
Positioning and tone decide who we attract
We do not have to please everyone. In fact, being a little sharp or different can help. Some marketers build a tone that repels most people but deeply connects with the rest. That 1 percent who loves our style will often be ready to pay premium prices and commit long term.
Think of it this way. There are lots of agencies targeting the same type of business. Our copy, attitude, and offer are a filter. They pull in clients who like how we talk and how we work. The rest keep scrolling. That is fine. We want clients who fit our style and who stick with us when things get hard.
Execution matters more than the niche
One big reason people fail is not niche choice. It is stopping too early. We chase shiny new methods instead of doing one thing well. Too many jump from tactic to tactic when the first hurdles appear.
There is no market that will be easy. Every business vertical has problems. The trick is to push through the hard parts and improve with each client. The people who persevere get results. The ones who quit look for an easier fix and rarely find one.
Practical steps for directory outreach and positioning
If we decide to use directory outreach, follow these steps to avoid real conflict and win more clients:
- Pick a clear niche and a limited set of services to offer.
- Create a unique message that shows how we solve one or two big problems for that industry.
- Use templates as a base but personalize outreach for each prospect. Small changes increase response rates a lot.
- Test different tones and keep the one that brings in the clients we want to work with.
- Keep running the playbook long enough to refine the offer and the pitch.
Small tweaks matter. For example, in one campaign we found one state had a much higher response rate. That can happen for many reasons. When something works, double down on it. When it fails, change one variable and test again.
Polarize to attract the right clients
We do not need to be polite to everyone. A bold voice will turn off many prospects, and that is okay. The ones it attracts are already aligned with our style. They will sign faster and stay longer.
Use plain, direct language in outreach. Make the offer and the price clear. Tell prospects who we help and who we don't. That saves time and brings higher-quality leads.
Keep it simple and stick with it
Success looks like steady work and repeating the same steps. We get better when we do the same outreach and sales process over and over. Specializing reduces guesswork. It makes every call and email more effective.
Quick checklist before you start directory outreach
- Is the niche large enough? If yes, proceed. If not, consider a new niche or region.
- Do we have a clear offer that solves a common problem?
- Is our copy unique and on-brand?
- Can we commit to running the outreach for several months?
- Do we track response rates and tweak one variable at a time?
FAQ
If someone else in our group uses the same directory and copy, will prospects get annoyed?
Not usually. Prospects see many messages every day. They choose what speaks to them. If our message is clearer or fits their style, they will pick us. Personalizing outreach also avoids sounding generic.
What if the niche is crowded in my city?
Move to a nearby area or narrow the service within the niche. Focus on a subset of clients that others ignore. That is often faster than trying to outspend competitors.
How do we stand out if many agencies target the same niche?
Own a tone and a clear offer. Use direct, simple language. Say who we help and who we do not help. Specialization and repetition will build proof and higher conversions over time.
Should we change our copy if others copy ours?
We should always test and improve. If others copy our base template, we can stay ahead by refining messages, adding case studies, and personalizing outreach. That gives us a real edge.
How long should we stick with one outreach method?
Give it time. Run a method long enough to collect data and learn. Quick switches make it hard to get consistent results. If a method clearly fails after careful testing, then try a new one.
Final thought
Overlap in directory outreach is not the real problem. Worrying about who else is doing the same thing wastes energy. Focus on message, on who we want to attract, and on execution. Pick a niche. Run the playbook. Improve the offer. The wins will follow.