Understanding Declining Keywords and Domain Penalties in SEO


When a website's keywords are in a constant decline, it can be a cause for concern. This blog post will delve into potential reasons for this decline, explore the concept of domain penalties, and provide actionable insights for recovery. Let’s unpack these issues and see how you can address them effectively.

Table of Contents

Identifying the Issue: Keyword Decline

If your website's keywords have been declining for the last 30 days, it's essential to diagnose the underlying issue. Several factors could be at play, including:

  • Domain Penalty: This occurs when Google penalizes your domain due to violations of its guidelines.
  • Link Penalty: A penalty related to poor quality or toxic backlinks can significantly affect your rankings.
  • Content Quality: Low-quality or duplicated content can lead to a decline in search visibility.
  • Technical Errors: Issues such as crawl resistance or poor site structure may hinder your site's performance.

Before making changes or publishing new content, it’s crucial to identify the specific cause of the decline. Simply altering keywords without addressing the root issue will likely yield no improvement.

Understanding Domain Penalties

Domain penalties can stem from various sources. To recover, you need to understand why your domain was penalized in the first place. Some common reasons include:

  • Over-Optimization: Excessive keyword usage can signal to Google that your site is trying to manipulate rankings.
  • Spammy Backlinks: A poor backlink profile with low-quality links can trigger penalties.
  • Technical Errors: Problems like slow loading times or broken links may lead to a negative user experience, which Google considers.

To identify the specific reason for your domain's penalty, conduct a thorough audit of your site. Use tools like Google Search Console to check for any manual actions or algorithmic penalties. If your homepage doesn’t rank for its domain search, it’s a strong indicator of a penalty.

Got SEO Questions? Get answers every week at 4pm ET at Hump Day Hangouts. Ask questions ahead of time, or live – just go to: https://semanticmastery.com/hdho (bookmark this!) 10+ years of insights given every week!

Get your checklist to help get better results with GBPs, faster. 

Taking a Holistic Approach to SEO

SEO is a multifaceted discipline. A successful SEO strategy requires balancing various components, including content quality, technical SEO, and link building. If one area is lacking, it can affect your overall performance. Here are a few strategies to ensure a holistic approach:

  • Content Audit: Regularly review your content for quality and relevance. Update or remove outdated content.
  • Backlink Analysis: Monitor your backlink profile to identify and disavow toxic links.
  • Technical SEO Check: Use SEO tools to identify technical issues such as crawl errors or slow site speed.
  • Keyword Research: Regularly update your keyword strategy to reflect changes in search behavior.

Recovering from a Domain Penalty

If you've identified a domain penalty, recovery can be challenging. Here’s a structured approach to navigate the recovery process:

  1. Identify the Cause: Use Google Search Console and other tools to pinpoint the specific issue.
  2. Correct the Issue: Address the identified problems, whether they are related to content, backlinks, or technical aspects.
  3. Monitor Changes: After making adjustments, monitor your site’s performance over the following weeks.
  4. Consider Domain Transfer: If recovery efforts fail, transferring to a new domain might be necessary. This can isolate your new site from previous penalties.

For example, one case involved a multi-location tree service brand that faced a domain penalty. The owner switched from a .net to a .org domain and created standalone sites for each location. This strategy allowed for better management of penalties and improved overall search performance.

FAQs

What is a domain penalty?

A domain penalty occurs when Google penalizes a website for violating its guidelines. This can result from over-optimization, spammy backlinks, or technical errors.

How can I check if my site has a penalty?

Use Google Search Console to look for manual actions. Additionally, perform a domain search on Google; if your homepage doesn’t appear in the top results, it may indicate a penalty.

What should I do if my keywords continue to decline?

Conduct a thorough audit of your site, checking for quality content, backlinks, and technical issues. Address the root causes before making any keyword changes.

Is transferring to a new domain a good solution?

If all recovery efforts fail and your site remains penalized, transferring to a new domain can be a viable option. Ensure you create quality content and a strong backlink profile for the new domain.

How important is a holistic SEO approach?

A holistic approach ensures that all components of SEO are addressed, reducing the risk of penalties and improving overall site performance. Each area of SEO is interconnected, so deficiencies in one can impact others.

In conclusion, understanding the factors contributing to a decline in keywords is crucial for any SEO strategy. By identifying penalties, taking a holistic approach, and implementing recovery strategies, you can improve your website's performance and regain lost rankings.

For those who are looking to enhance their local SEO strategies, consider exploring resources such as the Local SEO Toolkit for agency owners and freelancers or check out the GMB Process Checklist for more structured guidance on optimizing your Google Business Profile.