Why Citation Vault Is NOT Like Yext or BrightLocal


A lot of SEOs confuse Citation Vault with tools like Yext or BrightLocal—but they’re completely different animals. Yext and BrightLocal manage real business listings. Citation Vault behaves more like a private blog network (PBN). In this post, we break down exactly how we use Citation Vault safely, why it should never point directly to your money site, and the simple buffer strategy that keeps your link profile strong without creating risk.

Table of Contents

Citation Vault vs Listing Management Services

Yext and BrightLocal help you place and manage business listings. These services submit your business name, address, phone, and website to many directories. They are meant to make your local listing consistent and visible. You can point those listings directly to your main website. That is how they work.

Citation Vault is not that. It is a network of pages that publish content with links. That setup looks more like a PBN. A PBN is a group of sites used to push link signals. Citation Vault pages will often use URL anchors. They can be spammy if not used with care.

“Citation Vault is a PBN network.”

Because they act like a PBN, we treat Citation Vault differently. We do not send those links straight to the money site. We never point Citation Vault at the main site. Instead, we use a buffer or an ID page to absorb that layer.

We follow a simple plan. First, we create an ID page or buffer site. Then we point Citation Vault to that page. After that, we build higher quality links that point to that same ID page or to the money site from relevant places. This builds a layered link profile without making our main site look spammy.

Here is our step-by-step approach:

  • Create an ID page or buffer site that is tied to the brand. This can be a Google Site, a branded web 2.0, or a small page on a separate domain.
  • Set up Citation Vault so its links go to the ID page, not the money site.
  • Use the brand name as the visible anchor that points to the ID page. In practice, many Citation Vault links will still be URL anchors. But the visible link we want to create is a brand anchor that points to the ID page.
  • Let the Citation Vault pages provide a base layer of branded anchors. Only a small portion of the many pages will actually get indexed, but they still add a cushion of brand signals.
  • Build better, topical links that point to the ID page and to the money site. These links use keyword anchors and are from sites with real relevance.
  • Use the ID page as a buffer so the money site does not get hit directly by lower-quality signals.

This process creates a “pillowing” effect. The base layer of brand anchors softens the overall anchor text mix. Then we can be more aggressive with keyword anchors in later link layers without making the anchor text profile look weird.

Got SEO Questions? Get answers every week at 4pm ET at Hump Day Hangouts. Ask questions ahead of time, or live – just go to: https://semanticmastery.com/hdho (bookmark this!) 10+ years of insights given every week!

Free GBP Ranking Checklist

Get your checklist to help get better results with GBPs, faster. 

Why We Use an ID Page or Buffer Site

Pointing Citation Vault to a buffer keeps the main site safe. The buffer shows brand signals. It absorbs low-quality links. It also lets us control which anchors show up next to the brand anchors.

Think in layers. The Citation Vault links give the brand layer. Then we add topical links that carry keyword signals. Those topical links are higher quality and more relevant. They can point at the money site or the ID page as needed.

We do this because many Citation Vault pages do not get indexed. There used to be cases where nearly all 300 pages would index. Now that rarely happens. We might get 50 or 60 indexed. That smaller group still creates a base of brand anchors but in a modest, safer way.

Citation Vault vs Yext/BrightLocal: The Clear Difference

Yext and BrightLocal are directory tools. They create public business listings on real sites and directories. Those links are normal citations. It is correct to point them to your main website. They help local SEO by keeping NAP consistent and by adding directory signals.

Citation Vault is a link network. It is a tool to publish many pages that include links. It is not a directory manager. It does not replace proper citations. It should not be used like a listing tool.

Anchor Types We Use and Why They Matter

We use three anchor types in our link mix:

  • Brand anchors: These use the brand name or URL. They are safe and natural. Citation Vault gives us a base of brand anchors.
  • Top topic anchors: These are keyword-only anchors. They show what the page talks about without a location. For example, “plumbing repair” as an anchor.
  • Target anchors: These add a location to the keyword. For example, “plumbing repair Seattle.” These are more specific and often more powerful for local search.

We like to set the anchor text ratio so that brand anchors dominate. That leaves room to use top topic and target anchors in higher-quality links. If too many keyword anchors appear from low-quality sources, the anchor profile looks spammy. The brand base helps avoid that look.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

People make the same errors with Citation Vault again and again. Here are the top mistakes and what we do instead:

  • Mistake: Pointing Citation Vault straight to the money site. Fix: Always point to an ID page or buffer site.
  • Mistake: Expecting all 300 pages to index. Fix: Plan for only a fraction to index. Use the base layer for brand signal, not raw power.
  • Mistake: Treating Citation Vault like a citation manager. Fix: Use directory tools like Yext or BrightLocal for real citations that link to the main site.
  • Mistake: Relying on the Citation Vault UI to set brand anchors everywhere. Fix: Verify links. Many pages will still show URL anchors regardless of the UI setting.

Recommended Buffer Types and What to Put on an ID Page

You can use simple and cheap buffers. The point is to make a page that looks real and is tied to the brand. Here are some options and what to include:

  • Google Sites: Easy and fast. Free. Good for a light buffer.
  • Branded web 2.0: Use a platform like Medium, WordPress.com, or similar. Match the brand look.
  • Small independent page: A separate domain or subdomain with a single page that mentions the brand and services.

What to put on the ID page:

  • Brand name and logo.
  • A short description of services.
  • Contact info or a soft NAP (name, address, phone). It can be partial if you do not want to create an extra listing.
  • Links to the main website using the brand name as the anchor.
  • Some short content that shows relevance to the niche or city.

Keep it simple. Make sure the page is clearly connected to the brand. That way, the Citation Vault links look like they point to a brand asset, not to the money site itself.

When to Use Citation Vault

We use Citation Vault as one layer in a larger plan. It helps when we need more branded anchors quickly. It also gives us a cushion before we add more aggressive, keyword-rich links.

Do not use it as your only link source. Use it with other link types that have real topical relevance. Mix in local signals, directory citations, and links from real local sites.

FAQ

Is Citation Vault safe to use?

It can be safe if used properly. Never point it directly at your money site. Use a buffer or ID page. Use it as a base layer and then add higher quality links on top.

Can we use Citation Vault instead of Yext or BrightLocal?

No. They do different jobs. Yext and BrightLocal handle real business listings and citations. Those should link to your main site. Citation Vault is more like a PBN and should be treated differently.

How many Citation Vault pages actually index?

Less than the full set. In the past, many pages indexed. Today, far fewer do. You might see 50 or 60 pages index out of 300. Count on a small fraction rather than the full amount.

What anchors should we use on the ID page?

Use brand anchors to the money site. Let the ID page show brand strength. Then use targeted links from good sources with top topic and target anchors as needed.

Should business directory listings go to the ID page or the main site?

Directory listings should go to the main site. Tools like Yext and BrightLocal are for directories. They help local SEO when they point to the money site.

Can Citation Vault hurt our site?

Yes, if misused. Direct low-quality links to the money site can make your anchor profile look spammy. Use the buffer method and a balanced link plan to avoid harm.

Final Notes

Citation Vault is a tool. It has a place in our work but it is not the same as citation managers. We treat it as a PBN-type layer and we protect the main site from direct exposure. Use brand anchors as the base. Add better links after that. Use Yext or BrightLocal for real citation work and point those to the main site. Follow the layering plan and you will get the benefits without the risk.

If we stick to that plan, we can use Citation Vault smartly. It will serve as a cushion that lets us be more aggressive with higher quality link building. That mix is what moves the needle in local search.