Have you ever noticed your new website showing up on Google’s search results, maybe on page 3, 4, or 5, and then suddenly it vanishes? You check, and the site is still indexed, but it’s nowhere to be found in the rankings. This is a frustrating problem many website owners face, and it often leaves you wondering, “What happened?”
We’ve seen this happen a lot, especially after Google releases algorithm updates. In this article, we’ll explain why your site might disappear from rankings even though it’s still indexed, what could be causing it, and what you can do to recover your site’s visibility. Let’s get into it.
Table of Contents
Why Does My Site Disappear From Google Search But Stay Indexed?
When a website is indexed by Google, it means Google knows about your site and has added it to its database. However, being indexed doesn’t guarantee your site will show up in search results. Sometimes, sites remain indexed but drop out of the rankings completely. This can happen for several reasons, but one of the most common causes is an algorithm update from Google.
For example, the Google Spam Update in December 2024 caused many sites to suddenly lose their rankings. These sites were still indexed, but they disappeared from search results and stopped getting traffic. The update targeted spammy or low-quality sites, but some sites got caught up by accident, even though they weren’t doing anything wrong.
This kind of thing happens regularly whenever Google updates its search algorithms. Google tries to improve search quality, but sometimes good sites get hit along the way. If you notice your site disappears out of nowhere but remains indexed, it’s likely the result of an algorithm update like this.
Other Google Issues That Can Affect Your Site
Not only do algorithm updates cause ranking drops, but sometimes Google’s own features can have bugs or issues. For instance, Google Business Posts—updates you make on your Google Business Profile—have been disappearing or not showing up for many users recently.
This is probably a bug on Google’s side. Google Business features can be buggy and may break temporarily until Google fixes them. Unless Google officially announces they are removing a feature, it’s safe to assume the problem will be fixed soon. So, if you’re noticing Google Business Posts not showing, don’t panic—it’s likely just a temporary issue.
Got SEO Questions? Get answers every week at 4pm ET at Hump Day Hangouts. Ask questions ahead of time, or live – just go to: https://semanticmastery.com/hdho (bookmark this!) 10+ years of insights given every week!
Get your checklist to help get better results with GBPs, faster.
How to Know If Your Site Has a Penalty
Sometimes, when your site disappears from search results, it’s because Google has penalized it. There are two main types of penalties:
- Manual Penalties: These happen when a real person at Google reviews your site and finds it breaking their rules. You will get a notification in Google Search Console if this happens.
- Algorithmic Penalties: These happen automatically when Google’s system detects problems with your site. You won’t get a manual notification, but you’ll see drops in traffic and rankings.
If your site is still indexed but you see a big drop in impressions and clicks in Search Console, and there’s no manual penalty notification, you’re probably dealing with an algorithmic penalty.
How to Recover When Your Site Disappears
Recovering from a ranking drop after an algorithm update or penalty can be tricky. Here are some strategies you can try:
1. On-Page Optimization
Improving the content, structure, and SEO elements on your site can sometimes help you recover. Make sure your pages have clear titles, good keywords, useful content, and a great user experience. Fix any technical SEO issues like slow page speed or broken links.
On-page fixes are usually easier to do and can help if the penalty is related to the quality of your content or site structure.
2. Check for Link Penalties
Sometimes, bad backlinks pointing to your site can cause Google to penalize you. These are called off-page penalties. Cleaning up your backlink profile by removing spammy or low-quality links can help, but it’s often a long and difficult process.
Recovering from link penalties can take months, and sometimes it’s not possible to get back your rankings completely.
3. Change Your Domain
If you’ve tried everything and your site still isn’t recovering, one of the fastest ways to bounce back is to move to a new domain. This means creating a new website address and starting fresh.
We’ve seen this work well in practice. For example, one of our long-term clients had a tree service website that got hit by an algorithmic penalty. Despite months of efforts, the site didn’t recover. So, we moved individual locations to subdomains on a new domain and rebuilt their presence. While it wasn’t a perfect recovery, it helped regain many of the lost rankings.
Changing domains can feel like a big step, but it sometimes saves a lot of time and frustration compared to trying to fix a penalty that won’t go away.
What to Do If You See Your Site Disappear
If your new site is performing well initially and then suddenly disappears from Google search results, here’s a quick checklist to follow:
- Check if your site is still indexed by searching
site:yourdomain.comon Google. - Look in Google Search Console for any manual action notifications or messages.
- Review your site’s traffic and impressions data to see if there’s a sudden drop.
- Consider if there was a recent Google algorithm update that might have affected your site.
- Review your on-page SEO and content quality.
- Analyze your backlink profile for any spammy or harmful links.
- If recovery attempts don’t work, think about moving to a new domain and rebuilding.
Be Patient and Keep Learning
Google’s search algorithms are always changing. Sometimes your site will get caught in updates or bugs, and it can feel like your hard work disappears overnight. But by understanding what’s happening and taking the right steps, you can recover and keep growing your online presence.
Remember, if your site disappears but is still indexed, it’s often an algorithmic issue rather than something you did wrong. Keep monitoring, optimizing, and if needed, don’t be afraid to start fresh with a new domain.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Why is my site still indexed but not showing in Google search results?
Being indexed means Google knows about your site, but it doesn’t guarantee ranking. Your site may be penalized by an algorithm update or affected by bugs, causing it to disappear from search results while still being indexed.
What is the difference between a manual penalty and an algorithmic penalty?
A manual penalty is applied by a Google employee after reviewing your site and finding rule violations. You will get a notification in Google Search Console. An algorithmic penalty happens automatically when Google’s system detects problems, and there is no manual notification.
How do I know if my site has been hit by a Google algorithm update?
Look for sudden drops in traffic and rankings, especially after known Google update dates. Check SEO news sites and forums where updates are discussed. Also, review Google Search Console for changes in impressions and clicks.
Can I recover from a Google penalty without changing domains?
Yes, sometimes improving your on-page SEO and cleaning up bad backlinks can help recover your rankings. However, recovery can be slow and difficult, especially with link penalties.
When should I consider changing my domain?
If you’ve spent months trying to recover from a penalty without success, changing your domain and starting fresh can be the quickest way to regain rankings and traffic.
Why do Google Business Posts sometimes disappear?
Google Business Posts can be buggy and may not show up temporarily due to technical issues on Google’s end. Unless Google announces the feature is ending, it’s likely a temporary bug that will be fixed.