Why Your Rankings Dropped (And How to Fix It!)


When your brand search tanks, it feels like the floor just dropped out from under your business. One week you own the entire front page—socials, citations, your site at the top—and the next, leads are gone. Most people panic and start guessing: “Was it the citations? Should I add them back?” That’s the wrong move. The truth is simple: you don’t fix brand search drops by guessing, you fix them by testing. In this post, I’ll walk you through the exact checks we run to pinpoint what actually happened, rule out noise, and rebuild brand signals that last.

Table of Contents

Quick summary

  • If a brand search stops showing your site, it could be many things: site changes, algorithm issues, or a penalty.
  • Removing social links and citations might matter, but it may be a coincidence.
  • Never assume. Test changes, reindex pages, and track results.
  • We give a checklist you can use right now to find and fix the problem.

What likely happened

We hear this often. A site used to show up when people searched the brand. Then it stopped. Leads fell. The owner removed or changed some social links and citation listings on the homepage. Now they wonder if putting them back will fix everything.

Here is the honest take: removing links to social profiles and citations could have an effect. It could also be nothing. SEO is full of timing and side effects. That is why we always test.

“If you make an assumption, well, make an ass out of yourself. You have to test everything.”

Step-by-step approach to diagnose the drop

We recommend doing checks in this order. Each step is simple and gives you a clear answer or next action.

  1. Check Google Search Console (GSC)
    • Look for manual actions under Security & Manual Actions.
    • Check Coverage and Indexing to see if pages were dropped or blocked.
    • Use Performance to filter by the brand query and see when impressions and clicks fell.
  2. Verify site changes and timing
    • Pinpoint when rankings fell. Did it match a site change? A DNS or hosting move? A major edit to the homepage? A change to robots.txt or canonical tags?
    • If the timing matches removing social links or citations, that could be a clue—still test.
  3. Look for algorithm updates
    • Check public SEO update logs for the date range of the drop. Some updates affect specific site types or signals.
  4. Search for brand query competition
    • Is another site now outranking you for the brand? Maybe a new page, an aggregator, or social network is taking the spot.
  5. Check backlinks and link changes
    • Did you lose important backlinks? Or did spammy links suddenly appear? Either can cause drops.
  6. Audit structured data and entity signals
    • Brands benefit from clear entity signals: consistent name, phone, address, business profile, citations, and social profiles. If those were removed, it weakens the entity profile.

Got SEO Questions? Get answers every week at 4pm ET at Hump Day Hangouts. Ask questions ahead of time, or live – just go to: https://semanticmastery.com/hdho (bookmark this!) 10+ years of insights given every week!

Free GBP Ranking Checklist

Get your checklist to help get better results with GBPs, faster. 

Why brand searches behave differently

Brand searches are usually easy wins. If users type your exact brand name, Google often shows your site at the top. So when that disappears, it tells us something changed at the domain level or in how Google recognizes the brand as an entity.

Two common causes:

  • Domain-level penalty or filtering. If Google applies a manual action or algorithmic filter, your site can lose visibility even for brand queries.
  • Brand ambiguity. If your brand name is very generic or similar to many other brands, Google might not treat searches as clear brand queries. That makes rankings fragile.

Brand ambiguity example

If you name your company “Smith Plumbing” in a market with many “Smith Plumbing” listings, Google has a hard time deciding which result is the true brand. That makes your presence weaker unless you build a strong, unique entity profile.

Short answer: test it.

Here is how we do that:

  1. Add the social links and citation references back to the page if you removed them.
  2. Use Google Search Console to request reindexing for the homepage or main pages.
  3. Watch performance over the next 7–30 days. Look for rank or impression improvements.
  4. If you see improvement, great. If not, keep digging.

Why this works: testing gives us data. If adding the signals back moves the needle, we know those signals matter. If nothing happens, then the root cause lies elsewhere and we can rule out the social/citation factor.

Other things to try right away

  • Check for accidental noindex, disallowed pages, or broken canonical tags.
  • Confirm the Google Business Profile (GBP) is verified and consistent with the site.
  • Restore any site content or links that were removed recently and were helpful for recognition.
  • Audit the homepage content. Is your brand name and unique info clear and consistent?
  • Run a backlink audit. Remove or disavow obvious spam if you see a surge of bad links.
  • Check analytics to see where traffic fell and which pages lost the most visibility.

How to recover if it’s a penalty

If GSC shows a manual action, we must fix what Google flagged and submit a reconsideration request. If it’s algorithmic, we look for patterns: thin content, unnatural links, or on-page issues. Fix the issues, show remediation steps, and then monitor recovery. This can take weeks or months depending on the problem.

Brand building to make rankings durable

Long term, we focus on building a strong, clear brand signal. Here are simple actions that help:

  • Keep your business name, address, and phone consistent across the web.
  • Keep active, accurate social profiles that link back to your site.
  • Create unique content about your business and your team on the site, especially on the homepage and About page.
  • Earn links from real local sources and industry sites—links that show authority.
  • Use schema markup for organization, local business, and contact info so Google can read entity details easily.

What to watch after you make changes

We track three things after any change:

  1. Rankings for the brand query and related queries.
  2. Clicks and impressions in Google Search Console.
  3. Actual leads and conversion metrics in analytics.

If rankings rise but leads do not, the issue may be user experience, page content, or conversion paths. Fixing visibility is only part of the problem. We must also make sure the site converts visitors into leads.

Checklist: Quick tests to run right now

  1. Open Google Search Console. Check manual actions and coverage.
  2. Search for your brand in an incognito window. See what shows on the front page.
  3. Add back any removed social links and citation mentions on the homepage.
  4. Request indexing in GSC for the homepage after edits.
  5. Check robots.txt and meta tags for accidental blocks.
  6. Audit recent content edits and roll them back if needed.
  7. Review backlinks and spike patterns. Disavow spam if required.
  8. Confirm Google Business Profile info is complete and correct.

Common mistakes we see

  • Assuming cause without testing. A change and a drop that happen at the same time are not always linked.
  • Overreacting to short-term rank dips. Wait a week or two after changes to judge effect.
  • Ignoring brand uniqueness. A generic name makes recovery harder.
  • Not using GSC data. It tells you where the problem may live.

Final thoughts

When a brand drops, don’t panic. Start with data. Test simple fixes like re-adding signals. Use Google Search Console and analytics to guide your moves. If re-adding citations and socials helps, you’ve learned something useful. If not, keep testing other hypotheses. SEO is rarely fixed by a single change. It is a process of testing, measuring, and iterating.

FAQ

Q: If I add back citations, how long until I see results?

A: It can take a few days to a few weeks. Request indexing in Google Search Console after you add them. Then watch GSC and ranking tools for changes. Small tests usually show signs within one to four weeks.

Q: Can removing social links really hurt brand rankings?

A: It might. Social and citation links are signals that help Google see an entity online. But the effect varies by site and brand strength. The only way to know is to test by adding them back and tracking results.

Q: How do we know if the drop is a penalty?

A: Check Google Search Console for manual actions. Also look for sudden, large traffic drops that affect many queries. Penalties are rarer than other causes, but they do happen. If you see a manual action, fix the issue and submit a review.

Q: Our brand name is generic. What should we do?

A: Make the brand more distinct online. Use consistent citations and profiles. Publish unique content that ties your name to specific services, location, or people. Build trusted local links. Over time these signals will help Google treat your name as a real brand.

Q: What if we test and nothing works?

A: Keep testing. Check other areas like technical SEO, content, backlinks, and GBP. Consider hiring a specialist to do a full audit. Fixes can be simple or complex. The right diagnosis gets the right fix.

We hope this checklist gives you a clear plan. When in doubt, test and measure. That is how we find real fixes, not guesses.